| YEAR | GOVERNOR | HOMETOWN |
2023 | Silas Toppe | Mequon |
| 2022 | Luke Nemoir | New Berlin |
| 2019 | Dylan Bradley | Mequon |
| 2018 | Malik Staude | Oconomowoc |
| 2017 | Kellen Sharp | Milwaukee |
| 2016 | Kadin Hendricks | De Pere |
| 2015 | Jacob Malinowski | Greendale |
| 2014 | Anthony Mensah | Milwaukee |
| 2013 | Gustav Johnson | Grantsburg |
| 2012 | Harvey Buckner | Shorewood |
| 2011 | Matthew Walker | Wauwatosa |
| 2010 | Connor Zwick | Waukesha |
| 2009 | Rory Ferreira | Kenosha |
| 2008 | Billy Entringer | Mt. Calvary |
| 2007 | Osahon Okundaye | Neenah |
| 2006 | Joseph Beaudoin | Menomonee Falls |
| 2005 | Ignacio Meneses | Madison |
| 2004 | Walter Bond | Milwaukee |
| 2003 | Samuel Katz | Madison |
| 2002 | Marcus Lewis | Black River Falls |
| 2001 | Christopher Grace-Moore | Milwaukee |
| 2000 | Luke Naegele | Waukesha |
| 1999 | Bryan Lattimore | Milwaukee |
| 1998 | Michael Dyer | Wisconsin Rapids |
| 1997 | Andrew Krajnik | Mishicot |
| 1996 | Matthew E. Kopac | Whitefish Bay |
| 1995 | Jelani A. Canser | Milwaukee |
| 1994 | R. Teig Whaley-Smith | Milwaukee |
| 1993 | Timothy J. Seipel | Sheboygan |
| 1992 | Chivas O. Owens | Milwaukee |
| 1991 | Ge Vue | Kaukauna |
| 1990 | Lafayette Crump | Milwaukee |
| 1989 | Ernest H. Bivins | Milwaukee |
| 1988 | Peter Schiefelbein | Oshkosh |
| 1987 | Corey D. Woods | Milwaukee |
| 1986 | Dominic L. Williams | Milwaukee |
| 1985 | Karl S. Gashler | Abbotsford |
| 1984 | Philip A. Meyer | Greendale |
| 1983 | David P. Eich | Appleton |
| 1982 | James S. Kent | West Bend |
| 1981 | Dean M. Vernon | Milwaukee |
| 1980 | Vidur Mahadeva | Oshkosh |
| 1979 | Christopher R. Hutchison | Waukesha |
| 1978 | N. Neville Reid | Milwaukee |
| 1977 | Gregory D. Zlevor | Racine |
| 1976 | Kabir S. Mahadeva | Oshkosh |
| 1975 | Patrick J. Bruer | Eau Claire |
| 1974 | Bryan N. Massingale | Milwaukee |
| 1973 | David M. Kisner | Wisconsin Rapids |
| 1972 | Kenneth T. Ramsey | Milwaukee |
| 1971 | James F. Zender | Wausau |
| 1970 | Roger C. Berg | Shawano |
| 1969 | John Jungbacker | Oshkosh |
| 1968 | Keith Bakken | Mt. Horeb |
| 1967 | Tim Higgins | Appleton |
| 1966 | Gary McCartan | Wauwatosa |
| 1965 | Pat Toppins | Appleton |
| 1964 | David B. Marth | Wausau |
| 1963 | John I. Clark | Racine |
| 1962 | August Gnorski | Kenosha |
| 1961 | William Lacy | Port Washington |
| 1960 | Willie Rogers | Racine |
| 1959 | Charles W. Asher, Jr. | Sturgeon Bay |
| 1958 | Kevin Kersten | Milwaukee |
| 1957 | Alwin L. Jarreau | Milwaukee |
| 1956 | Thomas Hart | Milwaukee |
| 1955 | William A. Steiger | Oshkosh |
| 1954 | William J. Ellmann | Waupun |
| 1953 | Richard I. Aaron | Milwaukee |
| 1952 | Julius Tempkin | Beaver Dam |
| 1951 | Richard Holt Gascoigne | Kohler |
| 1950 | James K. Moore | Racine |
| 1949 | Kenneth Turner | Racine |
| 1948 | Allan R. Redman | Shawano |
| 1947 | J. William Murphy | La Crosse |
| 1946 | Henry B. Meyer | Richland Center |
| 1942 | Gerald De Motts | Sheboygan |
| 1941 | John R. Lewis | Eau Claire |
| 1940 | William Burton, Jr. | Appleton |
| 1939 | Ervin P. Wolfe, Jr. | Sheboygan |
